The Madison Fire Island Pines
Boutique guesthouse · Fire Island Fire Island Pines
Modern adults-only guesthouse in Fire Island Pines with a heated pool and roof terrace, close to the harbour and the Pavilion.
- 18+
- Heated pool
- Address
- 22 Atlantic Walk
11782 Fire Island - Season
- Pines summer season
- Crowd
- Adults, mostly gay men
- Facilities
- 9 rooms with private bathroom and air conditioning, breakfast, pool, roof terrace; prices about 250–500 US dollars per night
- Location
- Atlantic Walk, a few minutes from the harbour and beach
What makes The Madison Fire Island Pines special
The Madison is all about modern architecture with high ceilings and a glass front, plus a pool, roof deck and several outdoor areas. The team arranges beach gear, massages and restaurant tips. On Expedia it scores 8.8 out of 10. According to the booking site, housekeeping isn’t daily.
A good fit if you …
- want to stay centrally in the Pines
- appreciate a pool and roof terrace
Not ideal if you …
- are travelling with children
- are looking for a cheap room
Contact
Editorially researched, as of October 2026. Sources: themadisonfi.com, Expedia (8.8/10 from 52 reviews, latest review Sep 2026), Out x Out guides 2026. Opening hours, prices and programme may change, please check before visiting.
More in Fire Island
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.
*Affiliate link: if you book through it, we earn a commission. The price stays the same for you.